Menu ENN Search
Language: English Fran├žais

Post a reply: What is the reason the index of dispersion and its test vary in the ENA 'Results Antropometry' page and in the plausibility test

Use of en-net is subject to the Terms and Conditions.

WE have faced a situation when using ENA 2011 November version. What happened is the result of index of dispersion on the results anthropometry page and plausibility test are different. What is the reason for this discrepancy (see a result from a survey for the two outputs below)? Another related question is that the plausibility test check the validity or quality of the survey based on the age data. This quality test is assuming a developing country with high mortality rate in the under five population (based on the default on the option page). But it is obvious that there are different scenarios of mortality for the under fives, including very small or no mortality, fast declining mortality and what not. The second question will be is there any default that account for this variability and make the plausibility check more usable? (Or is there any work by demographers to account for specific contexts?). Many think that if we get penalized for not conforming with the softwares default the survey quality are poor; which is not the case according to SMART training. Your help in this is highly appreciated. Results of ID from ENA results page WHZ < -2: ID=0.74 (p=0.883) WHZ < -3: ID=0.92 (p=0.607) GAM: ID=0.74 (p=0.883) SAM: ID=0.92 (p=0.607) HAZ < -2: ID=1.68 (p=0.005) HAZ < -3: ID=0.98 (p=0.513) WAZ < -2: ID=1.37 (p=0.063) WAZ < -3: ID=1.15 (p=0.241) Results of ID from the plausibility word page: Test if cases are randomly distributed or aggregated over the clusters by calculation of the Index of Dispersion (ID) and comparison with the Poisson distribution for: WHZ < -2: ID=0.86 (p=0.718) WHZ < -3: ID=1.08 (p=0.342) GAM: ID=0.86 (p=0.718) SAM: ID=1.08 (p=0.342) HAZ < -2: ID=1.39 (p=0.055) HAZ < -3: ID=1.04 (p=0.404) WAZ < -2: ID=1.11 (p=0.297) WAZ < -3: ID=0.91 (p=0.638)
To add a URL link click the chain button within the editor and enter a URL
Please give your real name

Your email will not be displayed on the website
Optional

Your question will be manually approved before it appears on the website. We reserve the right to delete any inappropriate messages.