Menu ENN Search
Language: English Fran├žais

SAM cases

This question was posted the Prevention and treatment of severe acute malnutrition forum area and has 4 replies.

» Post a reply

Normal user

5 Mar 2014, 13:17

we found in screening report high number of SAM cases comparing to MAM, in last quarter the proportion of SAM to MAM approximately 2:1, is this realistic or can be acceptable \, the normal is 1:4 or 1:3 SAM to MAM , What is the expected justification for such situation Thank you

Anonymous 730

Nutrition and Food Security Officer

Normal user

5 Mar 2014, 13:26

With screening, you cant really expect a normal distribution of SAM:MAM cases, as the sampling is probably not representative, ie. children with SAM or MAM may form the greater number. The reason is that your sampling method is non-probability sampling.

Anonymous 81

Public Health Nutritionist

Normal user

5 Mar 2014, 14:16

I think it is difficult to generalize the proportion of SAM to MAM. I don't think there is internationally agreed cutoff point regarding proportion of MAM to SAM. for example, if there is outbreak of diseases, there could be high case of SAM. Back to your question, there could be different factors. some of these could be; 1. The screening place or site - is it community/village level screening or health facility screening or CMAM sites? 2. what is the context of the area? - is there ongoing nutrition intervention programs? sometimes some agencies implement only SFP. 3. what the public health situation? - high prevalence of morbidities such as diarrheal disease could distort the normal pattern

Mark Myatt

Epidemiologist at Brixton Health

Frequent user

5 Mar 2014, 18:11

The ratio you give is quite unexpected. I have looked at a database of 500+ survey (SMART type) datasets and calculation the MAM:SAM ratio. There is quite a range: id muac.sev muac.mod who.sev whz.mod muac.ratio whz.ratio ---------- -------- -------- ------- ------- ---------- --------- afgh01.csv 0.90 6.90 2.60 3.85 7.67 1.48 afgh02.csv 0.23 10.65 1.49 3.32 46.30 2.23 afgh04.csv 0.64 5.90 0.21 4.08 9.22 19.43 afgh05.csv 2.09 11.00 2.09 7.37 5.26 3.53 afgh06.csv 1.08 13.71 1.62 7.56 12.69 4.67 afgh07.csv 5.65 23.89 6.51 12.17 4.23 1.87 afgh08.csv 2.41 11.81 2.89 4.82 4.90 1.67 afgh09.csv 2.17 17.35 2.39 7.37 8.00 3.08 afgh10.csv 2.16 7.78 2.48 6.38 3.60 2.57 afgh11.csv 0.98 7.72 1.85 4.56 7.88 2.46 afgh12.csv 0.54 5.39 0.76 4.53 9.98 5.96 afgh13.csv 0.43 4.11 0.76 4.10 9.56 5.39 afgh14.csv 1.47 13.58 2.63 8.95 9.24 3.40 afgh15.csv 0.64 4.79 0.75 2.98 7.48 3.97 afgh16.csv 0.74 7.01 2.23 5.53 9.47 2.48 afgh17.csv 1.73 12.62 3.24 8.19 7.29 2.53 afgh18.csv 3.13 19.96 3.76 10.76 6.38 2.86 afgh20.csv 4.55 22.65 7.32 15.46 4.98 2.11 afgh21.csv 1.59 6.77 2.43 5.08 4.26 2.09 afgh22.csv 1.59 14.61 6.86 11.03 9.19 1.61 afgh23.csv 0.56 8.89 2.11 6.56 15.88 3.11 afgh24.csv 0.21 6.26 1.25 3.55 29.81 2.84 afgh25.csv 3.97 24.97 3.45 12.33 6.29 3.57 afgh26.csv 5.00 22.71 5.10 13.23 4.54 2.59 afgh27.csv 0.53 5.90 1.37 7.59 11.13 5.54 afgh28.csv 0.54 9.56 1.71 4.12 17.70 2.41 afgh29.csv 1.76 15.89 2.05 5.42 9.03 2.64 afgh30.csv 1.51 11.75 1.51 5.82 7.78 3.85 afgh31.csv 0.75 9.75 0.90 3.15 13.00 3.50 afgh32.csv 2.80 16.00 0.78 4.92 5.71 6.31 afgh33.csv 2.00 17.49 4.5 10.75 8.75 2.37 afgh34.csv 1.68 11.53 1.68 7.44 6.86 4.43 afgh35.csv 1.43 9.26 1.76 4.97 6.48 2.82 afgh37.csv 5.31 14.29 4.90 4.90 2.69 1.00 alba01.csv 0.10 2.21 0.55 3.98 22.10 7.24 ango01.csv 2.98 16.56 2.76 5.08 5.56 1.84 ango02.csv 1.38 7.06 1.20 3.62 5.12 3.02 ango03.csv 0.56 6.79 1.22 4.12 12.13 3.38 ango04.csv 0.81 11.07 2.93 5.70 13.67 1.95 ango05.csv 1.02 9.63 2.04 4.30 9.44 2.11 ango06.csv 0.62 5.56 1.23 5.07 8.97 4.12 ango07.csv 0.74 2.98 1.49 3.35 4.03 2.25 ango09.csv 0.62 4.02 0.93 1.55 6.48 1.67 ango10.csv 14.22 32.00 13.78 16.00 2.25 1.16 ango11.csv 4.34 13.59 3.56 7.13 3.13 2.00 ango12.csv 3.67 20.31 2.36 6.29 5.53 2.67 ango13.csv 2.38 14.21 2.03 5.38 5.97 2.65 ango14.csv 2.02 13.92 1.01 3.93 6.89 3.89 ango15.csv 0.66 2.53 1.10 1.43 3.83 1.30 ango16.csv 6.16 15.27 6.41 9.20 2.48 1.44 ango17.csv 1.54 13.42 2.31 4.70 8.71 2.03 ango18.csv 11.97 24.79 13.11 14.81 2.07 1.13 burm01.csv 1.51 11.41 1.83 6.46 7.56 3.53 burm02.csv 0.75 7.47 1.60 2.46 9.96 1.54 burm03.csv 0.64 11.56 0.75 4.60 18.06 6.13 burm04.csv 3.82 20.70 5.29 16.76 5.42 3.17 burm05.csv 2.47 21.44 6.73 12.91 8.68 1.92 burm06.csv 1.88 15.17 4.65 12.40 8.07 2.67 burm07.csv 2.00 17.20 3.66 10.55 8.60 2.88 burm08.csv 1.57 13.51 3.25 16.96 8.61 5.22 buru01.csv 0.11 6.86 0.10 1.03 62.36 10.30 buru02.csv 0.37 1.86 0.37 2.42 5.03 6.54 buru03.csv 0.19 2.87 0.96 2.11 15.11 2.20 buru04.csv 0.10 1.36 0.58 2.33 13.60 4.02 buru05.csv 1.11 13.68 2.11 5.90 12.32 2.80 buru06.csv 0.22 6.02 1.83 7.42 27.36 4.05 buru07.csv 5.24 20.28 4.55 9.09 3.87 2.00 buru08.csv 3.99 17.09 3.99 7.03 4.28 1.76 buru09.csv 2.94 15.51 3.21 5.35 5.28 1.67 buru11.csv 2.76 14.75 5.07 8.29 5.34 1.64 buru12.csv 1.32 9.62 1.71 6.33 7.29 3.70 buru13.csv 4.10 15.14 4.84 10.20 3.69 2.11 buru14.csv 3.36 16.55 4.56 10.07 4.93 2.21 buru15.csv 2.79 10.37 3.34 7.36 3.72 2.20 buru16.csv 0.39 5.92 1.16 4.63 15.18 3.99 cafr01.csv 0.33 5.67 1.00 3.67 17.18 3.67 cafr02.csv 0.23 5.24 2.28 5.46 22.78 2.39 cdiv01.csv 0.22 5.56 0.89 2.00 25.27 2.25 cdiv02.csv 0.30 4.80 0.80 3.60 16.00 4.50 cdiv03.csv 0.48 5.76 1.63 4.61 12.00 2.83 chad01.csv 5.00 21.11 6.78 12.55 4.22 1.85 chad02.csv 2.09 14.65 4.96 9.03 7.01 1.82 chad03.csv 0.45 6.91 2.23 7.47 15.36 3.35 chad04.csv 2.33 9.11 4.11 9.33 3.91 2.27 chad05.csv 1.48 16.23 4.53 15.17 10.97 3.35 chad06.csv 1.75 13.10 5.57 15.50 7.49 2.78 chad07.csv 1.88 14.73 7.21 20.48 7.84 2.84 chad08.csv 2.31 15.86 3.89 15.23 6.87 3.92 chad09.csv 2.82 17.47 8.37 19.56 6.20 2.34 chad10.csv 1.05 13.01 4.72 16.27 12.39 3.45 chad11.csv 0.52 5.33 4.60 10.46 10.25 2.27 chad12.csv 0.57 13.11 4.84 17.67 23.00 3.65 chad13.csv 0.42 6.83 2.84 8.41 16.26 2.96 chad15.csv 4.82 27.55 12.40 24.22 5.72 1.95 chad16.csv 3.49 15.90 5.01 22.66 4.56 4.52 chad17.csv 1.15 9.01 2.54 9.24 7.83 3.64 chad18.csv 7.22 23.37 10.48 20.40 3.24 1.95 chad19.csv 1.80 18.67 4.50 13.61 10.37 3.02 chad20.csv 2.22 12.08 3.39 8.58 5.44 2.53 chad21.csv 0.84 9.28 2.43 7.59 11.05 3.12 chad22.csv 2.00 13.19 3.27 10.76 6.60 3.29 chad23.csv 0.88 13.61 5.26 21.28 15.47 4.05 chad24.csv 0.52 12.40 2.92 13.85 23.85 4.74 chad25.csv 1.88 12.32 6.05 18.69 6.55 3.09 chad26.csv 0.10 8.47 1.99 17.47 84.70 8.78 chad27.csv 5.00 23.95 15.26 27.63 4.79 1.81 chad28.csv 4.06 10.73 4.69 10.52 2.64 2.24 chad29.csv 0.21 8.23 3.44 16.77 39.19 4.88 chad30.csv 0.32 4.60 4.13 10.00 14.38 2.42 chad31.csv 0.63 5.16 3.07 10.81 8.19 3.52 chad32.csv 0.11 5.32 3.10 10.63 48.36 3.43 chad33.csv 0.10 2.84 1.14 5.68 28.40 4.98 drcz01.csv 0.80 10.40 1.26 4.34 13.00 3.44 drcz02.csv 2.68 6.03 3.58 4.69 2.25 1.31 drcz03.csv 0.33 2.12 1.00 2.67 6.42 2.67 drcz04.csv 0.45 5.47 0.89 3.13 12.16 3.52 drcz05.csv 2.46 5.58 3.12 5.14 2.27 1.65 drcz06.csv 6.80 8.62 7.14 5.90 1.27 0.83 drcz07.csv 1.36 8.60 0.79 2.94 6.32 3.72 drcz08.csv 1.22 5.67 3.23 4.89 4.65 1.51 drcz09.csv 2.34 9.58 3.67 8.58 4.09 2.34 drcz10.csv 1.01 6.59 2.79 5.81 6.52 2.08 drcz11.csv 1.45 8.04 3.12 8.60 5.54 2.76 drcz12.csv 1.10 9.91 6.06 7.93 9.01 1.31 drcz13.csv 2.36 4.60 2.69 6.29 1.95 2.34 drcz14.csv 1.49 7.34 1.38 2.88 4.93 2.09 drcz15.csv 1.95 12.34 1.30 5.73 6.33 4.41 drcz16.csv 1.40 9.72 0.86 5.40 6.94 6.28 drcz17.csv 7.10 10.93 6.28 2.19 1.54 0.35 drcz18.csv 3.14 13.33 3.90 5.63 4.25 1.44 drcz19.csv 2.84 13.09 2.73 10.14 4.61 3.71 drcz20.csv 1.63 6.40 1.63 3.47 3.93 2.13 drcz21.csv 3.78 3.89 4.00 3.33 1.03 0.83 drcz22.csv 0.89 6.12 0.67 3.45 6.88 5.15 drcz23.csv 1.22 7.91 4.90 12.47 6.48 2.54 drcz24.csv 3.04 7.24 5.77 4.09 2.38 0.71 drcz25.csv 3.02 7.72 5.01 6.04 2.56 1.21 drcz26.csv 2.94 5.67 4.10 6.93 1.93 1.69 drcz27.csv 1.65 8.38 1.03 3.21 5.08 3.12 drcz28.csv 2.31 6.70 7.39 12.47 2.90 1.69 drcz29.csv 10.43 6.99 9.88 3.44 0.67 0.35 drcz30.csv 4.19 12.36 4.30 5.96 2.95 1.39 drcz31.csv 8.17 7.42 7.63 2.15 0.91 0.28 * drcz32.csv 2.20 1.21 2.53 0.77 0.55 0.30 * drcz33.csv 8.26 7.40 7.62 2.25 0.90 0.30 * erit01.csv 0.33 11.67 1.65 6.50 35.36 3.94 erit02.csv 0.78 9.81 3.01 9.25 12.58 3.07 ethi01.csv 0.33 5.23 0.67 6.01 15.85 8.97 ethi02.csv 3.16 20.24 5.01 14.03 6.41 2.80 ethi03.csv 0.44 8.45 1.56 5.67 19.20 3.63 ethi04.csv 0.62 2.77 1.23 4.22 4.47 3.43 ethi05.csv 0.89 13.01 2.11 7.68 14.62 3.64 ethi06.csv 0.77 12.43 1.54 9.24 16.14 6.00 ethi13.csv 0.10 7.02 1.34 7.44 70.20 5.55 ethi14.csv 2.66 11.36 4.40 9.52 4.27 2.16 ethi15.csv 2.38 12.20 3.93 9.31 5.13 2.37 ethi18.csv 0.62 3.23 0.83 5.00 5.21 6.02 ethi19.csv 2.16 9.59 3.30 7.22 4.44 2.19 ethi20.csv 2.26 9.14 2.26 8.42 4.04 3.73 ethi21.csv 1.30 9.62 1.70 7.92 7.40 4.66 ethi22.csv 0.66 8.65 0.88 4.49 13.11 5.10 ethi23.csv 0.66 4.65 0.66 2.22 7.05 3.36 ethi24.csv 0.99 16.52 3.08 12.67 16.69 4.11 ethi25.csv 0.55 9.18 0.44 3.60 16.69 8.18 ethi26.csv 1.07 7.06 0.96 4.07 6.60 4.24 ethi27.csv 0.87 7.07 0.37 3.60 8.13 9.73 ethi28.csv 0.37 5.55 0.62 2.34 15.00 3.77 ethi29.csv 1.11 8.46 2.12 9.13 7.62 4.31 ethi30.csv 0.55 8.43 2.11 7.42 15.33 3.52 ethi31.csv 1.93 16.11 2.69 12.99 8.35 4.83 ethi32.csv 0.99 12.67 1.80 11.59 12.80 6.44 ethi33.csv 0.57 11.45 1.53 8.68 20.09 5.67 ethi34.csv 0.97 13.44 2.26 11.18 13.86 4.95 ethi35.csv 0.55 12.29 1.54 10.97 22.35 7.12 ethi36.csv 0.29 6.97 0.79 6.97 24.03 8.82 ethi37.csv 0.11 7.12 1.78 9.01 64.73 5.06 ethi38.csv 0.11 11.62 1.77 12.17 105.64 6.88 ethi39.csv 0.22 7.73 0.66 7.19 35.14 10.89 ethi40.csv 0.22 12.61 2.10 9.74 57.32 4.64 ethi41.csv 0.44 12.17 1.64 11.30 27.66 6.89 ethi42.csv 0.74 5.32 2.34 9.26 7.19 3.96 ethi43.csv 0.33 7.33 1.11 5.33 22.21 4.80 ethi44.csv 0.39 5.46 1.56 6.82 14.00 4.37 ethi45.csv 1.39 10.73 2.58 7.83 7.72 3.03 ethi46.csv 3.47 16.27 4.34 10.09 4.69 2.32 ethi47.csv 2.89 15.41 4.82 12.91 5.33 2.68 ethi48.csv 1.27 8.06 2.65 13.89 6.35 5.24 ethi49.csv 0.52 10.90 0.42 4.93 20.96 11.74 ethi50.csv 8.95 28.37 6.43 14.88 3.17 2.31 ethi51.csv 4.20 22.42 1.91 8.15 5.34 4.27 ethi52.csv 1.42 12.27 2.71 9.05 8.64 3.34 ethi53.csv 0.36 8.50 1.58 8.13 23.61 5.15 eths07.csv 0.11 2.89 1.66 14.10 26.27 8.49 eths08.csv 0.44 2.18 1.31 8.72 4.95 6.66 eths09.csv 0.66 4.53 3.42 16.12 6.86 4.71 eths10.csv 0.22 5.02 3.06 15.72 22.82 5.14 eths11.csv 0.99 9.79 3.74 15.84 9.89 4.24 eths12.csv 0.88 3.51 4.39 13.48 3.99 3.07 eths16.csv 0.22 9.87 4.45 18.33 44.86 4.12 eths17.csv 1.00 9.79 6.02 15.06 9.79 2.50 guin01.csv 2.16 7.65 2.69 5.07 3.54 1.88 guin02.csv 0.24 8.84 0.72 3.94 36.83 5.47 hait01.csv 0.88 7.73 0.66 5.08 8.78 7.70 hait02.csv 0.22 3.66 0.33 2.77 16.64 8.39 hait03.csv 0.12 2.37 0.12 2.25 19.75 18.75 hait04.csv 0.54 4.86 0.86 3.57 9.00 4.15 hait05.csv 0.24 3.18 0.61 1.84 13.25 3.02 hait06.csv 0.44 4.09 0.11 3.43 9.30 31.18 hait07.csv 1.23 4.24 2.12 3.23 3.45 1.52 hait08.csv 0.54 3.37 0.87 2.50 6.24 2.87 hait09.csv 0.25 4.79 0.25 1.51 19.16 6.04 hait10.csv 0.61 4.27 0.98 2.93 7.00 2.99 hait11.csv 1.13 10.52 1.70 2.71 9.31 1.59 hait12.csv 0.67 3.24 0.89 3.24 4.84 3.64 hait13.csv 0.43 2.58 0.86 3.65 6.00 4.24 hait14.csv 1.30 6.30 1.74 4.12 4.85 2.37 hait15.csv 0.36 6.07 0.71 2.15 16.86 3.03 hait16.csv 1.00 1.71 0.29 1.71 1.71 5.90 hait17.csv 0.11 2.43 0.33 3.42 22.09 10.36 hait18.csv 0.78 6.44 1.00 4.44 8.26 4.44 hait19.csv 0.59 3.40 0.89 2.81 5.76 3.16 hait20.csv 0.26 3.33 0.38 1.92 12.81 5.05 hait21.csv 0.97 5.07 0.86 3.78 5.23 4.40 hait22.csv 0.77 7.90 0.77 4.17 10.26 5.42 hait23.csv 0.25 3.91 0.76 5.17 15.64 6.80 hait24.csv 0.33 2.93 0.22 2.49 8.88 11.32 hait25.csv 2.13 5.61 2.24 5.61 2.63 2.50 hait26.csv 0.45 9.29 1.90 7.06 20.64 3.72 hait27.csv 2.34 7.43 5.94 7.44 3.18 1.25 hait28.csv 0.10 4.35 0.47 2.95 43.50 6.28 hait29.csv 0.33 2.08 0.55 3.06 6.30 5.56 hait30.csv 0.11 2.71 0.54 4.33 24.64 8.02 indo02.csv 1.02 14.21 2.28 8.63 13.93 3.79 keny01.csv 0.87 7.58 6.72 20.04 8.71 2.98 keny02.csv 5.11 7.54 6.86 15.08 1.48 2.20 keny03.csv 1.00 3.54 3.43 17.17 3.54 5.01 keny04.csv 0.99 2.97 4.40 15.18 3.00 3.45 keny05.csv 1.89 8.10 5.33 12.87 4.29 2.41 keny06.csv 0.80 7.74 2.73 13.67 9.68 5.01 keny07.csv 0.98 4.89 7.60 20.74 4.99 2.73 libe02.csv 3.11 12.22 4.76 5.90 3.93 1.24 libe03.csv 0.27 5.96 2.71 4.61 22.07 1.70 libe04.csv 0.67 8.03 1.00 7.03 11.99 7.03 libe05.csv 0.32 6.82 1.30 6.82 21.31 5.25 libe06.csv 1.04 6.57 1.38 3.81 6.32 2.76 libe07.csv 0.44 11.78 1.11 6.89 26.77 6.21 libe08.csv 1.02 8.65 1.27 4.84 8.48 3.81 libe09.csv 0.75 8.99 0.37 7.50 11.99 20.27 libe10.csv 0.25 8.35 1.23 4.67 33.40 3.80 libe11.csv 0.71 5.65 1.65 3.06 7.96 1.85 libe12.csv 1.95 9.21 4.98 10.19 4.72 2.05 libe13.csv 1.87 12.82 5.07 10.68 6.86 2.11 libe14.csv 3.68 17.10 4.22 11.15 4.65 2.64 libe15.csv 0.43 6.07 1.84 3.69 14.12 2.01 libe16.csv 9.05 18.21 11.83 13.69 2.01 1.16 libe17.csv 3.40 10.32 6.46 10.09 3.04 1.56 libe18.csv 2.11 8.43 3.40 6.20 4.00 1.82 libe19.csv 0.25 3.23 0.50 1.49 12.92 2.98 libe20.csv 1.70 6.04 2.65 5.52 3.55 2.08 libe21.csv 1.25 8.10 1.60 4.22 6.48 2.64 libe22.csv 0.99 10.35 1.87 7.93 10.45 4.24 libe23.csv 0.89 8.36 1.17 5.92 9.39 5.06 libe24.csv 1.11 7.91 0.99 6.18 7.13 6.24 libe25.csv 1.71 11.14 1.95 5.29 6.51 2.71 libe26.csv 2.25 6.52 2.84 5.93 2.90 2.09 libe27.csv 1.70 10.40 2.55 5.52 6.12 2.16 libe28.csv 0.70 5.92 1.62 2.90 8.46 1.79 libe29.csv 0.33 4.98 1.66 4.32 15.09 2.60 libe30.csv 5.94 15.52 14.79 13.82 2.61 0.93 * libe31.csv 1.79 6.71 2.24 3.91 3.75 1.75 libe32.csv 0.49 2.81 0.98 3.29 5.73 3.36 mace01.csv 0.57 1.14 0.91 1.37 2.00 1.51 mala01.csv 2.28 3.20 3.65 2.97 1.40 0.81 mala02.csv 2.41 3.61 3.72 3.07 1.50 0.83 mala03.csv 5.28 16.29 9.66 10.23 3.09 1.06 mala04.csv 3.57 12.86 5.73 7.24 3.60 1.26 mala05.csv 3.18 10.82 4.67 5.83 3.40 1.25 mala06.csv 4.57 8.94 5.80 4.95 1.96 0.85 mala07.csv 3.40 10.10 5.23 6.98 2.97 1.33 mala08.csv 1.26 7.34 0.85 1.97 5.83 2.32 mala09.csv 1.45 10.05 1.22 2.74 6.93 2.25 moza01.csv 0.71 6.00 0.57 1.57 8.45 2.75 moza02.csv 2.24 12.31 1.87 5.97 5.50 3.19 moza03.csv 3.05 12.69 2.54 6.09 4.16 2.40 moza04.csv 4.76 12.70 8.57 10.80 2.67 1.26 moza05.csv 0.42 1.26 1.26 1.67 3.00 1.33 moza06.csv 1.83 4.57 1.37 5.02 2.50 3.66 moza07.csv 5.20 9.20 7.20 8.40 1.77 1.17 moza08.csv 10.10 18.82 10.10 12.55 1.86 1.24 moza10.csv 4.52 7.74 3.87 2.26 1.71 0.58 * nica01.csv 0.67 0.67 0.89 1.11 1.00 1.25 nica02.csv 1.23 1.06 1.41 0.53 0.86 0.38 nige01.csv 0.82 7.20 1.95 8.47 8.78 4.34 nige02.csv 2.59 13.35 4.50 13.76 5.15 3.06 nige03.csv 4.59 19.43 9.38 17.08 4.23 1.82 nige04.csv 4.71 18.27 7.79 12.98 3.88 1.67 paki01.csv 1.10 6.04 2.52 4.29 5.49 1.70 paki02.csv 1.90 10.70 3.57 6.13 5.63 1.72 paki03.csv 1.65 14.25 1.77 5.77 8.64 3.26 paki04.csv 0.34 5.94 1.71 4.80 17.47 2.81 paki05.csv 2.52 10.76 3.52 4.73 4.27 1.34 paki06.csv 1.33 6.67 4.56 13.44 5.02 2.95 paki07.csv 0.65 5.44 2.61 4.68 8.37 1.79 paki08.csv 1.74 7.63 1.85 3.38 4.39 1.83 paki09.csv 0.87 4.33 1.73 1.74 4.98 1.01 rwan01.csv 6.32 15.43 10.01 11.05 2.44 1.10 rwan02.csv 0.71 1.96 1.07 0.98 2.76 0.92 * rwan03.csv 0.64 4.01 1.12 0.97 6.27 0.87 * rwan04.csv 0.22 1.34 1.23 3.56 6.09 2.89 rwan05.csv 4.45 16.69 4.17 8.90 3.75 2.13 rwan06.csv 2.12 13.97 2.65 6.28 6.59 2.37 rwan07.csv 7.48 24.68 7.48 10.67 3.30 1.43 rwan08.csv 1.70 17.01 1.70 5.78 10.01 3.40 rwan09.csv 2.32 15.30 4.17 9.50 6.59 2.28 rwan10.csv 4.52 20.65 1.61 7.10 4.57 4.41 rwan11.csv 5.73 20.38 2.87 7.00 3.56 2.44 rwan12.csv 3.33 19.63 1.85 2.96 5.89 1.60 rwan13.csv 5.07 14.86 6.87 9.23 2.93 1.34 sier01.csv 1.78 8.99 1.54 5.68 5.05 3.69 sier02.csv 12.26 37.42 16.98 23.27 3.05 1.37 sier03.csv 7.73 23.91 11.44 14.58 3.09 1.27 sier04.csv 1.63 14.71 1.31 5.23 9.02 3.99 sier05.csv 7.52 24.01 11.24 14.75 3.19 1.31 sier06.csv 1.82 7.49 2.14 4.81 4.12 2.25 sier07.csv 0.63 10.55 0.95 5.80 16.75 6.11 sier08.csv 0.74 8.17 2.23 6.69 11.04 3.00 sier09.csv 0.33 6.79 2.67 5.01 20.58 1.88 sier10.csv 0.33 8.71 1.74 4.68 26.39 2.69 sier11.csv 0.47 9.68 1.75 6.18 20.60 3.53 sier12.csv 3.89 6.96 4.25 5.30 1.79 1.25 sier13.csv 0.31 5.56 1.34 7.00 17.94 5.22 sier14.csv 1.06 10.55 1.29 5.16 9.95 4.00 sier15.csv 2.12 8.03 1.67 5.24 3.79 3.14 sier16.csv 4.52 22.69 7.98 11.24 5.02 1.41 sier17.csv 3.44 20.11 5.44 12.23 5.85 2.25 sier18.csv 2.59 11.35 4.58 9.17 4.38 2.00 sier19.csv 9.88 27.16 9.65 19.87 2.75 2.06 sier20.csv 6.11 24.61 5.41 11.69 4.03 2.16 sier21.csv 1.06 13.18 1.63 6.18 12.43 3.79 sier22.csv 3.01 18.84 6.01 15.23 6.26 2.53 sier23.csv 1.56 8.44 2.00 7.78 5.41 3.89 sier24.csv 1.54 6.85 4.79 6.34 4.45 1.32 sier25.csv 4.03 14.83 4.66 8.90 3.68 1.91 sier26.csv 2.41 13.60 5.48 10.75 5.64 1.96 sier27.csv 0.89 9.78 1.33 4.11 10.99 3.09 sier28.csv 2.06 9.95 1.26 3.20 4.83 2.54 sier29.csv 0.79 9.59 1.35 3.73 12.14 2.76 sier30.csv 0.96 6.08 1.28 5.87 6.33 4.59 sier31.csv 1.46 9.94 1.99 5.65 6.81 2.84 sier32.csv 1.16 11.67 3.47 8.94 10.06 2.58 sier33.csv 2.47 21.93 6.97 15.98 8.88 2.29 sier34.csv 0.78 12.44 2.02 7.62 15.95 3.77 sier35.csv 1.59 15.11 2.73 10.45 9.50 3.83 sier36.csv 9.86 28.56 8.49 19.61 2.90 2.31 sier37.csv 4.86 15.82 3.62 10.39 3.26 2.87 sier38.csv 4.52 25.99 7.34 13.68 5.75 1.86 soma01.csv 1.38 1.80 4.76 11.64 1.30 2.45 soma02.csv 2.34 14.05 3.46 9.14 6.00 2.64 soma03.csv 8.60 28.45 11.69 17.64 3.31 1.51 soma04.csv 10.94 25.08 12.49 14.58 2.29 1.17 soma05.csv 1.41 13.74 2.42 9.30 9.74 3.84 soma06.csv 0.44 4.44 1.11 7.78 10.09 7.01 soma07.csv 0.97 6.80 2.75 7.77 7.01 2.83 soma08.csv 1.68 5.03 1.40 2.51 2.99 1.79 soma09.csv 1.79 22.47 6.56 12.92 12.55 1.97 soma10.csv 1.34 13.06 3.12 12.31 9.75 3.95 soma11.csv 0.61 5.49 1.83 1.52 9.00 0.83 * soma12.csv 2.53 18.99 3.38 10.97 7.51 3.25 soma13.csv 6.11 21.67 8.11 14.22 3.55 1.75 soma14.csv 6.48 28.75 9.79 11.69 4.44 1.19 soma15.csv 9.65 23.28 11.58 12.42 2.41 1.07 soma16.csv 3.33 16.27 6.84 12.20 4.89 1.78 soma17.csv 4.98 12.05 6.49 9.85 2.42 1.52 sril01.csv 0.78 8.80 3.12 15.70 11.28 5.03 sril02.csv 0.07 2.93 1.79 13.66 41.86 7.63 sril03.csv 1.37 3.75 5.12 15.70 2.74 3.07 sudd02.csv 0.53 4.86 0.85 5.92 9.17 6.96 sudd03.csv 0.44 2.83 1.74 5.67 6.43 3.26 sudd04.csv 0.11 4.25 0.78 7.60 38.64 9.74 sudd05.csv 0.24 10.15 5.13 16.51 42.29 3.22 sudd06.csv 1.78 17.39 8.03 15.72 9.77 1.96 sudd07.csv 1.79 17.00 5.70 16.78 9.50 2.94 sudd08.csv 1.45 16.46 3.00 16.91 11.35 5.64 sudd09.csv 1.56 21.43 7.92 19.87 13.74 2.51 sudd10.csv 0.21 5.36 2.84 10.93 25.52 3.85 sudd11.csv 0.10 2.98 1.34 5.45 29.80 4.07 sudd12.csv 0.42 10.01 2.74 14.86 23.83 5.42 sudd13.csv 0.32 3.68 0.97 3.79 11.50 3.91 sudd14.csv 0.24 4.28 0.59 4.76 17.83 8.07 sudd15.csv 1.88 13.54 5.10 11.67 7.20 2.29 sudd16.csv 0.62 2.29 1.35 8.86 3.69 6.56 sudd17.csv 0.73 9.29 3.55 14.93 12.73 4.21 sudd18.csv 0.31 4.38 1.77 9.06 14.13 5.12 sudd19.csv 1.67 15.15 6.17 18.70 9.07 3.03 sudd20.csv 0.10 6.05 1.77 9.92 60.50 5.60 sudd21.csv 1.68 9.04 4.73 11.04 5.38 2.33 sudd22.csv 0.73 5.00 2.56 13.78 6.85 5.38 sudd23.csv 0.31 5.10 2.29 15.73 16.45 6.87 sudd24.csv 0.21 6.77 2.40 15.31 32.24 6.38 sudd25.csv 1.88 9.79 4.27 15.11 5.21 3.54 sudd26.csv 2.61 14.72 7.72 19.63 5.64 2.54 sudd27.csv 0.72 16.47 4.53 19.81 22.88 4.37 sudd28.csv 0.22 13.05 3.98 18.59 59.32 4.67 sudd29.csv 4.68 19.47 15.11 22.55 4.16 1.49 sudn16.csv 0.53 5.07 1.80 4.64 9.57 2.58 sudn17.csv 0.31 5.42 1.98 8.23 17.48 4.16 sudn18.csv 2.20 6.16 4.95 10.34 2.80 2.09 sudn19.csv 2.63 18.11 4.11 13.15 6.89 3.20 sudn20.csv 9.58 28.41 14.12 19.00 2.97 1.35 sudn21.csv 2.40 11.23 5.49 13.72 4.68 2.50 sudn22.csv 0.96 7.46 3.30 8.96 7.77 2.72 sudn23.csv 0.51 5.01 1.53 8.08 9.82 5.28 sudn24.csv 1.07 7.24 5.09 13.94 6.77 2.74 sudn25.csv 0.85 8.70 5.31 11.25 10.24 2.12 sudn26.csv 0.74 8.55 2.60 12.27 11.55 4.72 sudn27.csv 1.23 10.98 4.64 17.24 8.93 3.72 sudn28.csv 0.74 4.68 3.20 9.61 6.32 3.00 sudn29.csv 0.36 9.11 3.04 12.32 25.31 4.05 sudn30.csv 0.51 10.66 2.54 13.70 20.90 5.39 sudn31.csv 0.21 5.56 1.68 5.66 26.48 3.37 sudn32.csv 0.52 7.13 2.62 11.11 13.71 4.24 sudn33.csv 0.56 7.01 2.11 9.68 12.52 4.59 sudn34.csv 0.88 9.68 3.81 14.37 11.00 3.77 sudn35.csv 0.84 15.27 3.56 19.56 18.18 5.49 sudn36.csv 0.94 9.83 4.39 16.64 10.46 3.79 sudn37.csv 0.10 9.11 4.08 12.36 91.10 3.03 sudn38.csv 0.73 6.82 2.62 13.22 9.34 5.05 sudn39.csv 0.64 10.29 3.75 17.47 16.08 4.66 sudn40.csv 0.52 8.71 2.41 17.21 16.75 7.14 sudn41.csv 0.43 9.70 3.09 16.21 22.56 5.25 sudn42.csv 1.00 13.27 6.02 16.50 13.27 2.74 sudn43.csv 0.89 10.90 4.78 15.69 12.25 3.28 sudn44.csv 0.78 10.57 4.78 19.14 13.55 4.00 sudn45.csv 1.00 9.33 5.11 16.00 9.33 3.13 sudn46.csv 1.64 17.42 9.42 20.48 10.62 2.17 sudn47.csv 5.60 23.20 12.20 25.40 4.14 2.08 sudn48.csv 1.95 11.69 8.01 20.99 5.99 2.62 sudn49.csv 1.32 11.31 8.01 23.82 8.57 2.97 sudn50.csv 3.81 13.77 10.38 18.43 3.61 1.78 sudn51.csv 0.94 8.92 1.68 7.55 9.49 4.49 sudn52.csv 0.92 13.35 1.53 7.03 14.51 4.59 sudn53.csv 0.93 9.28 1.03 6.81 9.98 6.61 sudn54.csv 0.51 10.05 1.62 6.81 19.71 4.20 sudn55.csv 1.84 12.77 1.84 5.92 6.94 3.22 sudn56.csv 1.67 11.00 3.11 7.78 6.59 2.50 sudn57.csv 1.72 11.72 2.69 8.92 6.81 3.32 sudn58.csv 2.60 20.93 5.97 18.43 8.05 3.09 sudn59.csv 0.83 9.47 2.60 9.00 11.41 3.46 sudn61.csv 1.12 12.79 3.15 7.61 11.42 2.42 sudn63.csv 1.25 8.34 4.31 11.96 6.67 2.77 sudn64.csv 2.22 3.73 3.63 9.76 1.68 2.69 suds01.csv 1.58 11.74 2.93 12.19 7.43 4.16 suds02.csv 2.20 12.53 4.40 17.14 5.70 3.90 suds03.csv 0.25 5.15 2.21 11.03 20.60 4.99 suds04.csv 2.05 8.22 5.71 10.73 4.01 1.88 suds05.csv 0.26 9.50 1.19 10.82 36.54 9.09 suds06.csv 0.63 9.15 2.00 9.04 14.52 4.52 suds07.csv 1.34 21.94 7.35 25.72 16.37 3.50 suds08.csv 2.21 10.66 4.41 18.75 4.82 4.25 suds09.csv 1.06 6.05 1.97 6.50 5.71 3.30 suds10.csv 0.97 9.96 4.33 17.21 10.27 3.97 suds11.csv 0.76 11.03 8.73 23.91 14.51 2.74 suds12.csv 0.45 11.88 5.83 18.39 26.40 3.15 suds13.csv 1.01 9.24 8.23 20.92 9.15 2.54 suds14.csv 0.71 18.59 2.59 13.65 26.18 5.27 suds15.csv 8.38 20.08 8.77 14.82 2.40 1.69 suds16.csv 0.93 20.68 6.48 22.07 22.24 3.41 suds17.csv 1.09 6.23 2.73 6.89 5.72 2.52 suds18.csv 5.85 25.60 11.49 19.76 4.38 1.72 suds19.csv 4.43 26.25 8.63 24.86 5.93 2.88 suds20.csv 0.87 15.03 3.49 13.72 17.28 3.93 suds21.csv 6.48 19.22 5.83 9.94 2.97 1.70 suds22.csv 1.12 10.01 4.16 10.69 8.94 2.57 suds23.csv 1.00 10.63 2.44 11.29 10.63 4.63 suds24.csv 2.77 16.34 6.59 13.83 5.90 2.10 suds25.csv 0.78 10.40 2.86 8.06 13.33 2.82 suds26.csv 2.18 24.16 16.11 27.01 11.08 1.68 suds27.csv 0.21 7.23 4.26 17.65 34.43 4.14 suds28.csv 1.42 9.43 2.36 10.38 6.64 4.40 suds29.csv 2.56 12.89 6.22 16.22 5.04 2.61 suds30.csv 7.56 17.89 10.33 15.56 2.37 1.51 suds31.csv 2.22 8.50 7.02 17.38 3.83 2.48 suds32.csv 2.33 12.33 11.22 21.56 5.29 1.92 suds33.csv 1.09 11.62 6.73 20.85 10.66 3.10 suds34.csv 1.45 5.07 4.59 14.25 3.50 3.10 suds35.csv 3.36 12.06 10.32 16.05 3.59 1.56 suds36.csv 2.66 16.95 8.23 13.92 6.37 1.69 suds37.csv 2.58 16.88 8.09 13.95 6.54 1.72 suds38.csv 5.07 17.20 18.07 23.39 3.39 1.29 suds39.csv 1.13 8.59 6.34 13.38 7.60 2.11 suds40.csv 9.82 18.75 9.15 21.99 1.91 2.40 suds41.csv 6.33 24.78 18.67 17.00 3.91 0.91 * suds42.csv 1.72 15.48 14.50 23.46 9.00 1.62 suds43.csv 0.80 4.39 3.59 12.50 5.49 3.48 suds44.csv 0.76 4.35 3.21 13.80 5.72 4.30 suds45.csv 0.80 4.91 3.45 13.95 6.14 4.04 suds46.csv 3.89 8.33 5.28 13.47 2.14 2.55 suds47.csv 2.22 17.89 12.33 26.00 8.06 2.11 suds48.csv 3.82 25.33 12.99 29.91 6.63 2.30 suds49.csv 2.87 22.72 10.11 22.22 7.92 2.20 suds50.csv 10.01 18.13 8.90 17.24 1.81 1.94 suds51.csv 0.69 3.58 2.19 14.67 5.19 6.70 suds52.csv 1.36 15.28 3.27 9.14 11.24 2.80 suds53.csv 0.22 5.67 1.74 10.80 25.77 6.21 suds54.csv 1.11 4.46 2.35 9.28 4.02 3.95 suds55.csv 3.57 10.03 5.80 11.15 2.81 1.92 suds56.csv 12.89 12.52 14.99 10.91 0.97 0.73 * suds57.csv 2.55 10.63 7.64 18.05 4.17 2.36 suds58.csv 1.74 14.21 7.16 17.24 8.17 2.41 suds60.csv 0.85 7.66 4.04 16.39 9.01 4.06 suds61.csv 1.00 5.44 2.89 12.33 5.44 4.27 suds62.csv 1.49 6.67 2.53 7.24 4.48 2.86 suds63.csv 0.13 3.93 3.05 11.54 30.23 3.78 suds64.csv 0.43 9.57 3.33 15.59 22.26 4.68 suds65.csv 0.21 16.70 3.70 16.91 79.52 4.57 suds66.csv 0.22 10.64 3.73 18.42 48.36 4.94 suds67.csv 3.10 6.21 6.87 9.32 2.00 1.36 taji01.csv 2.78 9.23 3.45 5.23 3.32 1.52 taji02.csv 9.57 20.47 10.90 7.12 2.14 0.65 taji03.csv 2.89 12.44 4.11 4.89 4.30 1.19 taji04.csv 6.40 14.00 6.93 8.67 2.19 1.25 taji05.csv 2.70 14.06 4.39 5.51 5.21 1.26 tanz01.csv 1.69 6.86 1.35 3.49 4.06 2.59 tanz02.csv 1.69 6.85 1.35 3.37 4.05 2.50 tanz03.csv 1.95 3.90 2.71 4.01 2.00 1.48 tanz04.csv 1.12 9.26 1.56 6.59 8.27 4.22 tanz05.csv 0.98 8.81 1.31 5.33 8.99 4.07 tanz06.csv 3.64 6.55 5.45 7.64 1.80 1.40 ugan01.csv 3.00 11.21 2.89 6.54 3.74 2.26 ugan02.csv 2.58 10.05 2.84 5.92 3.90 2.08 ugan03.csv 2.33 12.84 2.33 5.60 5.51 2.40 ugan04.csv 6.17 15.74 4.16 6.42 2.55 1.54 ugan05.csv 2.84 8.25 4.33 8.53 2.90 1.97 ugan07.csv 1.43 7.51 2.03 4.76 5.25 2.34 ugan08.csv 0.10 6.69 0.01 0.83 66.90 83.00 ugan09.csv 0.67 7.80 0.67 4.01 11.64 5.99 ugan10.csv 1.08 10.78 0.65 1.29 9.98 1.98 ugan11.csv 1.51 8.56 2.52 5.29 5.67 2.10 ugan12.csv 1.75 12.38 2.06 6.04 7.07 2.93 ugan13.csv 2.16 12.88 1.73 5.41 5.96 3.13 ugan14.csv 0.94 10.39 1.05 6.09 11.05 5.80 ugan15.csv 1.39 5.72 0.77 2.94 4.12 3.82 ugan16.csv 1.61 11.02 1.88 5.92 6.84 3.15 ugan17.csv 0.75 8.54 0.75 6.03 11.39 8.04 ugan18.csv 1.78 5.45 2.20 2.93 3.06 1.33 ugan19.csv 1.31 7.38 1.77 3.74 5.63 2.11 ugan20.csv 1.16 7.08 1.37 3.28 6.10 2.39 ugan21.csv 0.83 5.39 1.14 1.24 6.49 1.09 ugan22.csv 0.72 4.20 0.94 1.38 5.83 1.47 ugan23.csv 3.11 8.55 3.11 4.92 2.75 1.58 ugan24.csv 0.40 4.83 0.80 3.49 12.08 4.36 ugan25.csv 1.00 7.44 1.00 4.78 7.44 4.78 ugan26.csv 0.89 7.45 1.11 4.12 8.37 3.71 ugan27.csv 0.74 6.91 1.60 5.19 9.34 3.24 ugan28.csv 0.77 3.33 1.28 2.82 4.32 2.20 ugan29.csv 0.99 12.41 1.99 7.44 12.54 3.74 ugan30.csv 2.33 10.33 2.78 4.78 4.43 1.72 ugan31.csv 0.92 5.94 1.84 2.36 6.46 1.28 zamb01.csv 1.42 5.47 1.82 3.04 3.85 1.67 ---------- -------- -------- ------- ------- ---------- --------- Your 2:1 SAM:MAM ratio is 0.5 in the table above. There are only a handful of surveys with that ratio. I think that the reasons given by Anon730 and Kirros are correct. You are probably seeing the most wasted children coming for screening. I hope this helps.

Anonymous 490

SMART Survey Consultant

Normal user

6 Mar 2014, 04:03

This is very funny situation. It is the MAM cases that graduate into SAM. There is no way MAM cases can be less than the SAM cases. If the supervision was not done well, enumerators might have been measuring SAM cases only to make look like the area was not doing good nutritionally. I have done surveys for the last 7 years but I have never a case of the kind.

If you have any problem posting a response, please contact the moderator at post@en-net.org.

Back to top

» Post a reply