Menu ENN Search
Language: English Français

Manuscript reviewers

This question was posted the Prevention and treatment of severe acute malnutrition forum area and has 3 replies. You can also reply via email – be sure to leave the subject unchanged.

» Post a reply

Alexander

Clinical Nutritionist, KNH, Nairobi

Normal user

7 May 2018, 12:23

I am in the process of submitting my manuscript on "Caregivers' knowledge on severe acute malnutrition treatment objectives and perception of quality of care at Dadaab refugee camps, Kenya: a prospective cohort study, for publication with South Africa Journal of Child Health and I am stuck because I have been requested to suggest three reviewers. I have gotten one but I am not able to get two more. Please assist me to identify another two reviewers who have strong backgrounds in emergency nutrition.
.
Alexander- Kenya

Note from the moderator: if you would like to respond to Alexander via the moderator, please send to post@en-net.org

Mark Myatt

Consultant Epideomiologist

Frequent user

8 May 2018, 10:58

This is quite common practice. It save the journal a lot of time finding suitable reviewers and it save you a lot of time having to deal with reviewers' comments from reviewers who know little about the topic.

I often suggest one reviewer that I know and is likely to offer constructive criticism. I then suggest a one or two reviewers who have published decent (i.e. in my opinion) work on the topic or a related topic and / or have relevant methodological expertise. As a third reviewer I may suggest someone I know who will dislike the work (I have two regulars) as the challenge can improve the article and their responses can often be quite funny.

You do not need to personally know the reviewers. They just have to be relevant. I think you need people who knows SAM treatment, camp settings, and your "knowledge" method.

I hope this is of some help.

Rita Bhatia

Frequent user

8 May 2018, 13:57

Alexander
I can be one of the reviewers for your manuscript. My availability would be after 25
June.
Best, Rita

Martha

Frequent user

8 May 2018, 14:12

Hi Alexander,

Your list of reference would be a good place to start and like Mark has mentioned you do not need to know the reviewer just find authors who are publishing in your area of interest and most of the time their email addresses can be found on the publication.

Hope that is helpful,

Martha

Back to top

» Post a reply